Lincoln Wheat Penny Valued At $9 Million—Is It Still Circulating?

The idea of finding a Lincoln Wheat penny worth $9 million is the stuff of legends—maybe inspired by the rarity of 1943 copper anomalies.

In reality, no such sale has been documented, but ultra-rare variants, especially off-metal errors from the WWII era, have fetched hundreds of thousands up to over a million dollars.

Could one still be passed as pocket change today? Let’s delve into which Wheat pennies are truly valuable, how to identify them, and separate myth from numismatic fact.

What Makes Certain Wheat Pennies So Valuable?

Key value drivers include:

• Off-metal errors – pennies struck on unexpected planchets, like copper in 1943 when they should’ve been steel.
• Mintmark varieties – coins missing mintmarks or showing repunched mintmarks (RPMs) often have collector premiums.
• Condition (Grade) – high-grade specimens, especially in Mint State, can multiply base values dramatically.
• Historical significance – war-time changes in metal types, such as the zinc-coated steel cent, make off-metal penny varieties rare.

Notable Lincoln Wheat Penny Variants and Realistic Auction Value Ranges

Penny Type	Key Feature	Realized Value Range
1943 Copper – Denver	Bronze instead of steel	Over $1 M, real sales recorded
1943 Copper – San Francisco	Bronze anomaly from S mint	$500k–$1 M range
1943 Copper – Philadelphia	Rare off-metal strike	Up to $372k
1944 Steel Cent (S)	Steel striking after copper returned	Around $373k in top grade
1943–44 Misstrikes & Die Errors	Errors like die cracks	Up to $575k for rare die crack variants
1909-S VDB Penny	Low mintage key-date	Typically up to $168k
1955 Doubled Die Penny	Noticeable doubling on obverse	Sales up to $114k

Spotlight on the Rarest Wheat Penny Types

1943 Copper Penny (Denver)

Mistaken copper planchets were struck when the mint had switched to steel cents—creating perhaps the most legendary Wheat penny anomaly. One sold privately for over $1 million, though public auction records are lower.

1943 Copper Penny (San Francisco)

Another off-metal variant, less common than the Denver version, has sold in the $500k–$1 million range.

1943 Copper (Philadelphia)

Notably rare, with top-grade examples reaching close to $372,000.

1944 Steel Cent (S)

Steel pennies were phased out in 1943, yet a small batch was minted in 1944. High-grade examples have realized about $373k.

Other Wheat Penny Rarities

• Die crack errors on 1943 steel cents have fetched up to $575,000 for prominent examples with strong eye appeal.
• Classic rarities like the 1909-S VDB and 1955 doubled die are valuable—tens to hundreds of thousands—but still well below the million-dollar mark.

How to Examine Your Penny for Value

1. Use a magnet: Steel cents will stick, but genuine copper anomalies won’t.
2. Check the mintmark: Missing or doubled mintmarks are key identifiers.
3. Inspect condition: Crisp Wheat pennies with clear detail and minimal wear are much more valuable.
4. Compare weight: Steel cent ~2.7 g; copper cent ~3.11 g.
5. Authenticate: High-value finds should be verified and graded by professionals.

While a $9 million Wheat penny remains in the realm of legend, real treasures do exist. The genuine 1943 copper Wheat penny variants—especially from Denver, San Francisco, and Philadelphia—have reliably sold for hundreds of thousands, even crossing the million-dollar threshold.

If you spot a Lincoln Wheat cent that doesn’t stick to a magnet and has clean detail, consider submitting it for authentication—it just might be a rare piece of American numismatic history.

FAQs